Derek Carr's retirement has left the New Orleans Saints in a precarious position, paving the way for rookie Tyler Shough to potentially start in the 2025 season. This unexpected shift raises numerous questions for fantasy managers, particularly regarding the Saints' quarterback situation, which has been less than stable in recent years. The Saints selected Shough in the second round, but the lack of proven experience and past struggles of their other quarterbacks, such as Spencer Rattler and Jake Haener, cast doubt on the team's offensive prospects. The consensus among analysts is that Shough may be handed the reins despite his not-so-encouraging college statistics.

With the departure of Carr, who dealt with significant injuries, the Saints have officially entered a rebuilding phase at the quarterback position. This drastic change may lead to a lack of consistency and production on offense, impacting key players like Alvin Kamara and others. As fantasy owners ponder their strategies, the potential for a high draft pick to secure a future franchise quarterback adds another layer to the Saints' evolving narrative. The 2025 season could see the arrival of a top prospect as the Saints hope to find stability and return to competitive form.

Tyler Shough, a once highly touted quarterback, continues to navigate an uncertain path as he approaches the NFL Draft. Despite being a seven-year college player, his limited starting experience raises questions about his readiness for the pro level. His journey began at Oregon where he backed up Justin Herbert, and after stints at Texas Tech and Louisville, he finally started a full season. While he has shown promise with decent arm strength and pre-snap operation, his age and injury history are significant red flags for NFL teams. Analysts suggest he could be a solid late-round pick or a backup option, especially for teams needing depth.

Shough's age puts him in a precarious position, as he is older than many current college quarterbacks like Bo Nix and Jaden Daniels, who are also entering the draft. This age factor could negatively impact his draft stock, especially when considering previous trends of drafting older quarterbacks. If he can stay healthy and show consistency, he may find a niche as a backup quarterback, possibly in a team like Cleveland, looking for cheaper options to fill the roster.